"History is unlikely to change with Independence," anonymous Doctor
But voting ‘Yes’ will not change certain things. It will not be a final statement of our
position in Europe. It will not set in
stone what currency we use, or what wars we enter. All of those things will be determined by the
Governments we elect, just like most of our neighbours. Independence will not result in [insert
latest Unionist scare story here]. And finally,
there is something else that voting ‘Yes’ will not do.
One of the reasons often cited for voting no is the history
Scotland shares with England, Wales and Northern Ireland (the last 300 years,
not the millennia before). I have come
across those who argue that we need to be ruled from Westminster today because
that’s what we did when we stood against Hitler and the Nazis, communist USSR,
and countless other nations. This
argument makes even less sense than most for many reasons but let’s focus on
the most obvious one: becoming independent will not change history.
"Scotland might miss out on the next war!" No campaign threat?
Do we think less of the over 50,000 Canadian deaths during the First World War because they subsequently became independent? Or, would Canada continuing to be part of the empire during the Second World War have made any difference to its outcome? Such a statement would be condemned as ludicrous and yet this is the level of discourse of many within the no campaign.
There are countless other examples of why this ‘logic’ fails. What of the 1,500,000 (1.5 million) Indians
who died during the Second World War, did Indian independence lessen the
importance of their loss? Was it wrong
of Malaysia to become independent when 100,000 of their citizens died alongside
ours and those of other countries? Did
Indian and Malaysian independence make the world a less safe place?
"Westminster is the best place for these types of discussions to take place," says everyone at Westminster
The fact remains that the decision to become a sovereign
nation should be made by the people based upon their needs and wishes. Vague hints that doing what’s right will
somehow be an insult to the dead are wrong, not only in a practical sense, but
in a moral one too. Modern day wars are
often fought by many nations working together yet respecting each others
boundaries. Just as Denmark, Estonia, and
the Netherlands have important roles to play in NATO and other international
organisations, so would Scotland, however important decisions such as will we
go to war can only be made in Scotland if Scotland is independent; otherwise we
rely on the judgement of a government in Westminster who may not even have
popular support here.
Westminster logic
A ‘Yes’ vote will change many things, one of them being the quality
of discourse in our country, but our history will always remain the same.
Drew
If you like this blog, then please consider visiting our other sites:
Facebook - Sign for Scotland
YouTube - Sign4Scotland
Twitter - Sign4Scotland
Facebook - Sign for Scotland
YouTube - Sign4Scotland
Twitter - Sign4Scotland
No comments:
Post a Comment